The members of Katseye may be perfectly in sync when it comes to their dance moves, but their eye makeup is another story. When sharing her beauty secrets with Vogue, Daniela contrasts her signature look with that of her bandmate Yoonhchae.

“I feel like I have the complete opposite makeup look as Yoonchae,” the 22-year-old says. “First of all, Yoonchae doesn’t do a siren eye; she does the opposite. She does the doe eye. It looks so good on her face.” As for Daniela, she’ll opt for alluring over innocent eyes any day—and she has just the drugstore product to achieve the look.

After lining her eyes with jet-black wings, the Georgia native reaches for a tube of L’Oréal Paris Telescopic Mascara. “Holy grail,” she says of the product, which she’s been using since high school. While lightly brushing the tip of the wand back and forth over the ends of her lashes, Daniela explains, “I brush them more out for that siren look.”

There is one product Daniela and Yoonchae have in common, though: Anua Heartleaf 77+Hyaluron. “I’ve learned a lot—especially about skin care—with the girlies,” she says. “Honestly, I didn’t know anything about Korean skin care before coming into Katseye. That was a game changer, for sure.”

Shop Daniella Avanzini’s beauty routine, below.

Director: Gabrielle Reich, Nina Ljeti

DP: Paola Esquivel-Oliveros

Gaffer: David Djaco

Editor: Sara Rao

Senior Producer: Bety Dereje

Coordinating Producer: Lea Donenberg

Line Producer: Jen Santos

Production Manager: Kristen Helmick

Production Coordinator: Tanía Jones

Talent Managers: Lauren Mendoza, Randi Peck

Post Production Supervisor: Alexa Deutsch

Post Production Coordinator: Holly Frew

Supervising Editor: Kameron Key

Assistant Editor: Billy Ward

Filmed at: The Mercer Hotel